Shopify vs Etsy (2026): Fees, Traffic and Which Is Better for Sellers

By MarTechMeter Team

·

Shopify vs Etsy (2026): Fees, Traffic and Which Is Better for Sellers - MarTechMeter

Disclosure: MarTechMeter may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page, at no extra cost to you. This does not change our recommendations. Learn more.

Shopify vs Etsy is not really a like-for-like comparison. Etsy is a marketplace: buyers come to Etsy, and you rent a stall. Shopify is software for your own store: you own the shop, but you have to bring the traffic. Many successful sellers use both.

This guide compares costs, traffic, control and branding, using Etsy’s official Fees & Payments policy and help pages and Shopify’s pricing page as of October 2026.

Shopify vs Etsy at a glance

EtsyShopify
TypeMarketplaceYour own hosted store
Monthly feeNone required$29–$299/mo billed yearly
Per-sale fees6.5% transaction + 3% + $0.25 processing (US)Card rate from 2.9% + 30¢ on Basic
Built-in trafficYes, marketplace buyersNo, you drive traffic
Branding and designLimited shop customisationFull theme control and custom domain
Customer data and email listRestrictedYours
Best forHandmade, vintage, craft supplies, testing demandBuilding a brand and owned audience

Etsy fees explained

Etsy fee (US seller)AmountWhen it applies
Listing fee$0.20 per listingWhen published or renewed; listings last 4 months
Transaction fee6.5%Of item price plus shipping and gift wrap
Payment processing (Etsy Payments, US)3% + $0.25Of total sale incl. shipping and tax
Offsite Ads feeVariesOnly on sales attributed to Offsite Ads

Etsy’s policy states that the 6.5% transaction fee applies to the displayed price plus shipping and gift wrapping (US sellers do not pay it on sales tax), and that processing fees for Etsy Payments vary by the location of your bank account; for US accounts it is 3% + $0.25. Listing fees are charged whether or not the item sells, and auto-renewing a sold listing charges another $0.20.

Worked example: a $40 item with $5 shipping sold by a US seller: transaction fee 6.5% × $45 = $2.93; processing 3% × $45 + $0.25 = $1.60 (more if sales tax is included); plus the $0.20 listing fee. That is about $4.73, or roughly 10.5% of the order, before any ads.

Shopify costs explained

Shopify planPay monthlyPay yearly (per month)Online card rate (Shopify Payments)Third-party gateway fee
Basic$39$292.9% + 30¢2%
Grow$105$792.7% + 30¢1%
Advanced$399$2992.5% + 30¢0.6%
Plusfrom $2,300—from 2.25% + 30¢custom

On Shopify Basic, the same $45 order costs 2.9% + 30¢ = about $1.61 in card processing via Shopify Payments, but you also pay the plan fee every month whether you sell or not, plus any apps and theme. The break-even point depends on your volume: low-volume sellers often pay less on Etsy; higher-volume sellers usually pay less per order on their own store.

Traffic: the real difference

Etsy’s value is buyers who are already searching for handmade and unique items. You still compete with many similar listings, so photos, titles, tags and reviews matter. Shopify gives you no marketplace traffic: you need SEO, social media, email or ads. Our guides to Social Media Scheduling Tools and Best Email Marketing Software cover the tools most store owners use to build that traffic.

Control, branding and customer relationships

On Etsy, the platform sets the rules: shop design is standardised, policies can change, and contacting buyers for marketing is restricted. On Shopify you control the design, domain, pricing pages, upsells and, most importantly, the customer list. Owning your email list is what lets you sell repeatedly without paying marketplace fees on every order.

Using Etsy and Shopify together

A common path is to validate products on Etsy, then open a branded Shopify (or alternative) store and drive repeat buyers there. Inventory sync apps can connect both. Keep listings consistent, and use your own store for bundles, subscriptions and loyalty offers.

Etsy pros and cons

Pros

  • No monthly fee required
  • Built-in marketplace buyers
  • Very fast to start

Cons

  • Fees on every sale add up (~10% in our example)
  • Limited branding
  • Restricted access to customers
  • Heavy competition

Shopify pros and cons

Pros

  • Own brand, domain and customer data
  • Lower per-order processing on Shopify Payments
  • Scales with apps and channels

Cons

  • Monthly fee from day one
  • You must bring the traffic
  • Apps add cost

Alternatives for creators and subscription sellers

Shopify and its rivals are general-purpose store builders. If your business is narrower, a specialist can be cheaper and simpler:

PlatformBuilt forStarting price (Oct 2026)Transaction fees
SellfyCreators selling digital, subscription and POD products$22/mo billed yearly ($29 monthly)0%
SubblySubscription boxes and recurring productsfrom $69/mo1% + 12¢ on entry plan
SpocketSourcing dropshipping products for an existing store$39.99/mo (Starter)0% (Spocket listed)
WebflowDesign-led brands wanting full layout controlsee Webflow pricingsee Webflow pricing

Sellfy

Sellfy is a store builder for creators selling digital products, subscriptions, physical products and print-on-demand. Its pricing page lists Starter at $29/month ($22/month billed yearly, up to $10k sales per year), Business at $79 ($59 yearly, up to $50k) and Premium at $159 ($119 yearly, up to $200k), all with 0% transaction fees and a 14-day free trial. It is a good fit if you sell ebooks, courses, presets, music or merch and want a store running in an afternoon without apps.

Subbly

Subbly is a platform built specifically for subscription boxes and recurring products. Its pricing page says plans start from $69 a month with a 14-day free trial, and lists transaction fees such as 1% + 12¢ on its own payments (1.25% on other gateways) on the entry plan, with lower rates on higher tiers. If your entire model is recurring boxes, purpose-built subscription management (skips, gifting, pre-orders and churn tools) can save the cost and complexity of stacking subscription apps on a general store.

Spocket

Spocket is a dropshipping supplier marketplace that plugs into store builders. Its pricing page lists monthly plans of Starter $39.99, Professional $59.99, Empire $99.99 and Unicorn $299.99, cheaper when billed annually, plus a 7-day free trial. It sources products for a store rather than replacing one. It works alongside a store builder, so treat it as an add-on cost when budgeting.

Webflow

Webflow is a visual website builder with CMS and ecommerce plans, popular with designers who want full layout control. Check Webflow’s pricing page for the current site and ecommerce plan prices.

Which should you choose?

  1. Write down what you sell (physical, digital, subscriptions, handmade, dropshipped) and how many products you expect in year one.
  2. Estimate monthly revenue and multiply it by each platform’s card and transaction fees. At low revenue the plan fee dominates; at higher revenue, percentage fees matter more.
  3. List must-have features such as multi-currency, B2B pricing, bookings, product reviews or abandoned-cart email, and check whether each is native or needs a paid app.
  4. Check who maintains what. Hosted platforms handle security and updates; self-hosted software makes that your job.
  5. Start a free trial and build one real product page and a test checkout before you migrate everything.
  6. Plan your marketing stack: email, SEO and social tools often cost as much as the store itself.

See also Shopify Pricing Explained, Best Shopify Alternatives and the Ecommerce Platforms hub.

Frequently asked questions

Is Etsy cheaper than Shopify?

For low volumes, often yes, because Etsy has no required monthly fee. As volume grows, Etsy’s 6.5% transaction fee plus processing usually costs more per order than Shopify’s card rate.

What are Etsy’s fees in 2026?

For US sellers: $0.20 per listing, a 6.5% transaction fee on price plus shipping and gift wrap, and 3% + $0.25 payment processing via Etsy Payments, per Etsy’s official fee pages.

Can I link my Etsy shop to Shopify?

Yes, via third-party integration apps that sync products and inventory between the two.

Do I need my own traffic on Shopify?

Yes. Shopify does not provide marketplace traffic; you need SEO, social, email or ads.

Is Etsy good for digital products?

Etsy allows digital downloads, but dedicated platforms like Sellfy (0% transaction fees) are designed for creators who sell digital products from their own storefront.

Sources: Etsy Fees & Payments Policy; Etsy payment processing fees; Shopify pricing; Sellfy pricing. Pricing and plan details as of October 2026; vendors change prices often, so confirm on the official page before buying.

MarTechMeter Team

We test marketing & SaaS tools hands-on. How we test · Affiliate disclosure