Gusto vs OnPay (2026): Pricing, Features and Which to Choose

By MarTechMeter Team

·

Gusto vs OnPay 2026 payroll software comparison - MarTechMeter

Disclosure: MarTechMeter may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page, at no extra cost to you. This does not change our recommendations. Learn more.

Quick answer: Gusto is the better pick if you want payroll, benefits and growing HR tools in one polished app, starting at $49 a month plus $6 per person. OnPay costs the same to start but includes multi-state payroll and full support on its one plan, so it is usually cheaper for small teams spread across states.

Key takeaways

  • Gusto Simple and OnPay both start at $49 a month plus $6 per person, so a small one-state team pays the same on either.
  • Gusto Simple covers payroll in one state only. Multi-state payroll needs Gusto Plus at $80 a month plus $12 per person.
  • OnPay has one main payroll plan that includes all 50 states, unlimited pay runs and phone, chat and email support.
  • OnPay sells HR tools as an add-on for $15 a month plus $2 per worker, and gives new customers their first month free.
  • Gusto goes further on growth tools: time tracking and next-day pay on Plus, and a named advisor and HR guidance on Premium.

Terms used in this guide

  • Payroll software: A tool that figures out pay, takes out taxes, pays your team and files the tax forms for you.
  • Base fee: The flat monthly price you pay for the account, no matter how many people you pay.
  • Per-person fee: The extra monthly charge for each employee or contractor you pay.
  • Multi-state payroll: Running payroll for workers who live or work in more than one US state, each with its own tax rules.
  • Off-cycle payroll: An extra pay run outside your normal schedule, such as a bonus or a final paycheck.

How did we compare Gusto and OnPay?

Gusto and OnPay show up on almost every shortlist of small business payroll tools in the US. They do the same core job. Each one works out pay, takes out federal, state and local taxes, pays your team by direct deposit, and files the forms with the IRS and your state. So the real question is not “can it run payroll?” Both can. The question is what you pay for the extras you will need over the next two years.

We looked at both tools through the eyes of three owners. The first runs a five-person shop in one state. The second has ten people, and two of them just moved out of state. The third has 25 people across three states and wants someone to call about HR questions. For each one, we priced the plan they would really need and listed what they would still have to add.

All prices come from the official Gusto pricing page and the OnPay payroll page, checked in October 2026. We did not count taxes, benefits premiums or one-time promos unless we say so.

Gusto vs OnPay at a glance

GustoOnPay
Best forGrowing teams that want payroll, benefits and HR in one appSmall teams that want low, simple pricing with fewer limits
Starting priceSimple: $49/month + $6/person$49/month + $6/worker
PlansSimple, Plus ($80 + $12), Premium ($180 + $22)One payroll plan, plus add-ons
Multi-state payrollPlus and Premium onlyIncluded, all 50 states
Unlimited pay runsYes, every planYes
Tax filings, W-2s and 1099sIncludedIncluded
HR toolsBasic on Simple; more on Plus; HR guidance on PremiumHR add-on: $15/month + $2/worker
SupportBasic support on Simple and Plus; dedicated partner on PremiumPhone, chat and email support included
Accounting syncQuickBooks, Xero, FreshBooks and moreQuickBooks and Xero, among others
ContractMonth to monthMonth to month; first month free

How much does Gusto cost?

Gusto has three plans. Each one has a monthly base fee plus a fee for every person you pay. There is no long-term contract, and you can switch plans when you want.

Gusto planBase feePer personKey extras
Simple$49/month$6/monthPayroll in one state, unlimited runs, tax filings, basic PTO
Plus$80/month$12/monthMulti-state payroll, time tracking and scheduling, next-day pay
Premium$180/month$22/monthNamed advisor, HR guidance, business compliance, same-day pay

Two details matter more than they look. First, the Simple plan only runs payroll in one state. The day you hire someone who lives in another state, you need Plus. Second, US contractors are billed at the same per-person rate, but only in months when you actually pay them. That is fair if you use freelancers now and then.

Gusto also sells add-ons. Next-day pay costs $15 a month plus $3 per person on Simple, and it is included on Plus and Premium. Priority support costs $30 a month plus $3 per person on Simple and Plus. Same-day pay is $90 per payroll and instant pay is $100 per payroll unless you are on Premium.

How much does OnPay cost?

OnPay keeps it simple. There is one payroll plan at $49 a month plus $6 per worker. That plan already includes things Gusto saves for higher tiers, such as paying people in every state.

OnPay itemBase feePer workerWhat you get
Payroll$49/month$6/monthAll tax filings, W-2s and 1099s, unlimited runs, all 50 states
HR add-on$15/month$2/monthPTO management, custom workflows, document tools
Benefits integrationNo admin feeNo admin feeHealth insurance, workers’ comp and 401(k) synced with payroll

Every OnPay account comes with W-2s, 1099s, year-end filings, unlimited pay runs and expert support by phone, chat and email. OnPay also moves your employee data over for free and gives you the first month free. If you want more HR tools, like PTO management, custom workflows or document audits, the HR add-on is $15 a month plus $2 per worker.

OnPay also lists a time tracking add-on. Its partner price list shows $15 a month plus $4 per worker, so ask for a quote if you need it, since the price on your account may differ.

Which payroll tool is cheaper for your business?

Here is what five common businesses would pay each month at list price. We left out benefits premiums and taxes, since those cost the same no matter which tool you use.

Business (monthly list price)GustoOnPayCheaper option
5 employees, one state, payroll onlySimple: $79$79Tie
10 employees, one state, payroll onlySimple: $109$109Tie
10 employees in two statesPlus: $200$109OnPay, by $91
10 employees, one state, with HR toolsPlus: $200 (time tracking included)$144 with HR add-onOnPay, by $56
25 employees in three states, want an HR advisorPremium: $730$264 with HR add-on (no named advisor)OnPay on price; Gusto on hands-on help

The pattern is easy to see. For a small, one-state team that only needs payroll, it is a true tie. Once you cross a state line or want time tracking or HR tools, OnPay gets cheaper fast. That is because Gusto moves you to a higher plan where both the base fee and the per-person fee go up.

The last row is the honest exception. Gusto Premium costs much more, but it buys a named advisor, HR guidance and compliance tracking. If you would otherwise pay an outside HR consultant, that gap shrinks.

Which one is easier to use?

Gusto has the edge in polish. The dashboard walks you through each step, payroll takes a few clicks once it is set up, and the employee app is clean. New owners tend to feel at home in it within a day. That is a big part of why we gave it a high score in our full Gusto review.

OnPay is not hard to use. It is just plainer. Pay runs are quick, and the setup team does a lot of the work for you when you switch. We found it to be a “set it and forget it” tool, which is exactly what many small owners want. If looks and a slick mobile app matter to you, pick Gusto. If you just want payroll done right, OnPay is fine.

Which has better HR and benefits features?

Gusto is stronger here. It works as a licensed broker for health insurance with no admin fee, and it offers 401(k) plans, HSAs, FSAs, commuter benefits and workers’ comp. On Plus you get time tracking and scheduling. On Premium you get a named advisor, HR guidance and help staying compliant as you grow into new states.

OnPay covers the basics well. It syncs health insurance, workers’ comp and 401(k) with payroll, and it handles new hire reporting to all 50 states and DC for you. Its HR add-on adds PTO tracking, onboarding workflows and document tools. What it does not offer is the hands-on HR help of Gusto Premium.

Which one has better support?

This is where OnPay quietly wins. Phone, chat and email support are part of the main plan. You do not pay more to reach a person.

Gusto gives Simple and Plus customers basic support: a 24/7 help center plus phone and chat during business hours. If you want faster answers, Priority Support costs $30 a month plus $3 per person. Premium customers get a dedicated account partner. For a ten-person team on Simple, adding priority support raises the bill from $109 to $169 a month.

Do Gusto and OnPay work with your accounting software?

Both tools sync payroll costs to your books, so you do not have to type them in by hand. Gusto connects with QuickBooks, Xero, FreshBooks and many other tools, including Expensify, Homebase and Clover. OnPay lists QuickBooks and Xero in OnPay’s app directory, along with other apps.

If you are still picking accounting software, read our Xero vs QuickBooks Online comparison first. Both tools play nicely with either one.

Our scores

What we scoredWeightGustoOnPay
Price for a typical small team25%7/109/10
Ease of running payroll20%9/108/10
HR and growth features20%9/107/10
Support included in the price15%6/109/10
Benefits and integrations20%9/108/10
Weighted score100%8.18.2

OnPay edges ahead on our weights because most of our readers run small teams and care a lot about price and support. If you plan to grow fast and want benefits and HR help in one place, give more weight to growth features and Gusto comes out on top.

Gusto pros and cons

Pros

  • Clean, friendly app that new owners pick up fast
  • Strong benefits menu: health, 401(k), HSAs and FSAs
  • Grows with you through Plus and Premium
  • Lots of accounting and time-tool integrations
  • Unlimited payroll runs on every plan

Cons

  • Simple plan is limited to one state
  • Per-person cost climbs fast on Plus and Premium
  • Priority support is a paid add-on on lower plans
  • Many handy extras, like same-day pay, cost more

OnPay pros and cons

Pros

  • One plan with all 50 states included
  • Phone, chat and email support at no extra cost
  • Free data migration and first month free
  • Low-cost HR add-on instead of a pricier tier
  • Works well for nonprofits, farms and restaurants

Cons

  • App feels plainer than Gusto
  • Fewer built-in growth tools like a named HR advisor
  • Smaller integration list
  • Fewer pay-speed options advertised than Gusto

Who should choose Gusto, and who should choose OnPay?

Choose Gusto if you want the friendliest app, you plan to add health insurance and a 401(k) soon, or you expect to grow and want time tracking, an HR advisor and compliance help without switching tools later. It is also a smart pick if your accountant already works in Gusto.

Choose OnPay if you have workers in more than one state, you want phone support without paying extra, or you simply want the lowest fair price for solid payroll. Nonprofits, restaurants, farms and other businesses with simple needs often fit OnPay well.

Still deciding? Our list of the best payroll software for small business covers more options. If you hire people overseas, see Deel vs Gusto. If you want payroll tied to IT and device management too, read Rippling vs Gusto.

What does payroll software not do for you?

Payroll software files and pays your payroll taxes, but you are still the employer. You must classify workers correctly as employees or contractors, keep records, and make sure the bank account has enough money on payday. If a filing is wrong because of data you entered, you may still owe the penalty. the IRS employment tax guide is a good plain-language starting point on your duties.

How should you test Gusto and OnPay before you switch?

You do not need to guess. Here is how we suggest you try both in a week:

  • Write down your real setup. Count employees, contractors and states, and list the benefits you offer or plan to offer.
  • Price the full bill. Add base fees, per-person fees and every add-on you would need, like we did above.
  • Call support. Ask each company one tricky question, such as how they handle a worker who moves states mid-year. Note how fast and how clear the answer is.
  • Check the switch. Ask what data they will move for you and whether they handle prior quarter filings.
  • Pick a clean start date. Switching at the start of a quarter keeps tax filings simpler.

OnPay’s free first month makes a real test run cheap. Gusto is month to month, so you are not locked in either.

The bottom line

Gusto vs OnPay is closer than most comparisons. Both start at $49 a month plus $6 per person, both include tax filings and unlimited pay runs, and both are month to month. For a small team in one state, you can flip a coin on price.

The split comes as you grow. OnPay stays cheap because it includes every state and full support in one plan. Gusto costs more as you move up, but gives you a nicer app, more benefits and real HR help on Premium. Prices change, so check the Gusto pricing page and the OnPay payroll page before you sign up.

Frequently asked questions

Is Gusto better than OnPay?

Gusto is better if you want a polished app plus benefits and HR tools that grow with you. OnPay is better if you want low, simple pricing with all 50 states and full phone support included. For a small one-state team, both cost $49 a month plus $6 per person.

Is OnPay cheaper than Gusto?

For a one-state team on payroll only, they cost the same. OnPay becomes cheaper once you pay people in more than one state, because Gusto requires its Plus plan at $80 a month plus $12 per person for multi-state payroll.

How much does Gusto cost in 2026?

Gusto Simple is $49 a month plus $6 per person, Plus is $80 a month plus $12 per person, and Premium is $180 a month plus $22 per person. All plans include unlimited payroll runs and tax filings.

How much does OnPay cost in 2026?

OnPay payroll is $49 a month plus $6 per worker, with all 50 states, tax filings and support included. The HR add-on is $15 a month plus $2 per worker, and new customers get their first month free.

Do Gusto and OnPay file payroll taxes for me?

Yes. Both calculate, pay and file federal, state and local payroll taxes and produce year-end W-2s and 1099s. You are still responsible for giving them correct information and having enough money in your account.

Can I switch from Gusto to OnPay, or the other way?

Yes. Both are month to month, and both help move your employee data. Switching at the start of a quarter keeps tax filings simpler, so plan your move a few weeks ahead.

Sources: Gusto pricing; OnPay payroll and pricing; OnPay app directory; IRS employment taxes. Prices checked on official pages in October 2026. Vendors change pricing and promotions often, so confirm before you buy. This article is general information, not tax or legal advice.

MarTechMeter Team

We test marketing & SaaS tools hands-on. How we test · Affiliate disclosure